Looking for a tasty, filling, and quick meal? Grab these staples from your fridge and throw together a delicious and for the most part healthy BLT. Want the best recipe of all? You’re in the right spot! The winningest “best” BLT recipe is here!
Note- We left the “Leftover Test” score out on this one purposely… BLT’s are always best eaten immediately!
The contenders:
The nitty-gritty:
Each BLT was scored on a scale of 1-10 (where 1= that’s food? and 10= the best BLT that has ever entered my mouth) for overall score, the boyfriend/husband test, and the leftover test. We also provide other comments.
AllRecipes.com Super BLT
Overall score: 9
The boyfriend/husband test: 7
Comments: This was really good! I thought the guacamole gave it a nice creaminess and the cream cheese was an interesting way to substitute for mayo, while adding a bit of the cheese usually missing from most BLT sandwiches.
Kraft Recipe’s BLT
Overall score: 9.5
The boyfriend/husband test: 8.5
Comments: This is so simple, but it was SO good! It calls for a lot of mayonnaise (1 tbsp per sandwich), which I was initially hesitant about (mayo creeps me out.. is that normal?! Plus, it isn’t great for you), but it turned out to be the perfect amount! This was so good and easy that I made it again for dinner, and again for lunch the next day! And when I ran out of bacon, I went and bought more so I could keep making this. YUM.
Amazing Sandwiches’ BLAT
Overall score: 8
The boyfriend/husband test: 9
Comments: I know this is your basic BLT but the avocados gave it an extra good touch. This is a very good and easy for a quick lunch or light supper. Next time I would use 2 teaspoons of mayo as I felt there could have been a little more than the recipe recommended (1 teaspoon). My husband thought a slice of cheese would also enhance the flavor of this sandwich. I would make this one again for sure!
The winner:
Kraft Recipe’s BLT!
I guess this is another case where a classic is the best!
Special Diets:
While we can’t guarantee the results, here are some ideas you can use to customize the winning BLT to your dietary needs:
- Gluten-free: Use a gluten free bread for this one. Make sure your other ingredients are also gluten-free! Another creative option: Use the lettuce as your “bread” (sort of like a lettuce wrap).
- Vegetarian: Nix the bacon or use a bacon substitute, such as Lightlife Vegetarian Bacon-Smart Bacon.
- Vegan: Nix the bacon or use a bacon substitute, as described above. You can also make your own “bacon” out of tempeh. In addition, skip the mayo.
- Lower fat: Use less bacon, or use turkey bacon.
- Lower sugar/calories: You can cut the calories by using some of the suggestions above.






