With all the unhealthy things we have been testing lately, we figured it was time for something a little more attuned to bathing suit season. So, give it up for the “real best” salad!
The contenders:
Allrecipes Strawberry Spinach Salad
Allrecipes Jamie’s Cranberry Spinach Salad
Allrecipes Roquefort Pear Salad
The nitty-gritty:
Each salad was scored on a scale of 1-10 (where 1= that’s food? and 10= the best salad that has ever entered my mouth) for overall score, the boyfriend/husband test, and the leftover test. We also provide other comments.
Strawberry Spinach Salad

Overall score: 6
The boyfriend/husband test: 6
The leftover test: 4
Comments: This salad wasn’t bad, but there just wasn’t enough in it. There was a ton of spinach, and only strawberries and a tiny amount of silvered almonds as substance? Maybe the dressing was supposed to make up for it or something, but it wasn’t even that good. Jennifer picked the recipes this time, and I think she purposely gave me (Megan) the most boring, expensive, and fattening (see: the dressing) salad. To convince myself to bring this to work for lunch the next day, I added pecans and used a honey mustard dressing (side note: I highly recommend Bolthouse Farms dressings that are made with Greek yogurt!), and it was a little better. The salad holds up great for a few days (and I would know, because most of the leftovers sat in my fridge, uneaten, for quite a few days after), but the dressing does NOT do well in the fridge.
Jamie’s Cranberry Spinach Salad

Overall score: 7.5
The boyfriend/husband test: 8
The leftover test: 7
Comments: This salad was okay… I think it could have been much better with a raspberry-walnut dressing rather than the one in the recipe. It did taste much better chilled the next day but you have to make sure to keep the dressing separated from the spinach leaves otherwise they will wilt. Overall this is a very healthy salad with a little bit of extra punch to please a picky eater (i.e. husband thought it was actually really good!) but for a frequent salad eater, this is something I may make again, modified.
Roquefort Pear Salad

Overall score: 9
The boyfriend/husband test: 9
The leftover test: 8
Comments: To be honest, I didn’t think I was going to like this, but it was soo good! Even my husband loved it! Side note: I added red onions for color.
The winner:
Special Diets:
While we can’t guarantee the results, here are some ideas you can use to customize the winning salad to your dietary needs:
- Gluten-free: While this looks to be inherently gluten-free, double-check that all the ingredients are, in fact, gluten-free because you never know!
- Vegan: Leave out the cheese.
- Vegetarian: It already is!
- Lower fat: Use less or omit cheese, avocado, and pecans. (Although, the kind of fat that’s in avocado and in nuts is said to be good for you.. but I can’t say the same for the cheese!)
- Lower sugar/calories: Save 1/4 cup of sugar by not caramelizing the pecans.